Cabaret thrives during Christmas
Nothing says Christmas like suicide, drag queens and nudity. Well, at least in New York, where adults-only holiday entertainment has become a thriving subgenre.
Adults-only shows get avant-guard
By MARK BLANKENSHIP
Nothing says Christmas like suicide, drag queens and nudity. Well,
at least in New York, where adults-only holiday entertainment has
become a thriving subgenre.
And this season, the more outre alternatives to the Rockettes include
some major avant-garde names. For instance, genre-bending cabaret stars
Kiki and Herb -- the ageless lounge act alter egos of Justin Bond and
Kenny Mellman, respectively -- are following their consecration on
Broadway last season with a Dec. 12 holiday show at Carnegie Hall.
On Dec. 13, cult group the Tiger Lillies, best known for providing the
musical component in Off Broadway's "Shockheaded Peter," begin a
three-day run at St. Ann's Warehouse, performing an original concert of
morbid holiday numbers dubbed "Suicide for Christmas."
"Many people have an almost psychotic dislike of the festive season,"
says Tiger Lillies founder Martyn Jacques. "We thought we'd dedicate a
show to that group."
A far cry from the silky-smooth acts that grace the city's upscale
venues like Feinstein's or Cafe Carlysle, these shows also emphasize
the recent boom of alternative cabaret in Gotham. On almost any night,
auds can find burlesque dancers, zaftig trannies, bawdy singers and
off-kilter variety acts. The shows might be relatively high-profile --
like risque circus productions "Absinthe" and "La Vie," which ran in
the popular Spiegeltent this summer -- or they may be under the radar,
but there are plenty of them.
"People want something unusual and immediate," says David Foster, whose
Foster Entertainment Group is helping produce everything from "Kiki and
Herb" to "C'est Duckie," an "interactive nightclub performance
experience" in which patrons select individualized acts from a menu.
"They want to see a live performance that can't be replicated on film."
"Duckie," which had a successful London run, opens Dec. 20 at P.S. 122,
and Foster expects it to draw a different crowd than standard legit
"Though there will certainly be theater fans there, I don't think this
show will necessarily have a hardcore theater audience," he says. "I
think they're more of a downtown audience, more aware of the burlesque
world or live performance in general."
The opportunity to attract nontraditional crowds -- read: younger,
hipper and more adventurous -- is certainly attractive to many
producers. It's partly why the Zipper Factory, until recently a
standard Off Broadway presenting house, shifted its business model.
Instead of aiming for long runs of single shows, it now hosts a
repertory of concerts, sketch comedy, standup and performance art. Most
shows perform only a few times or on a handful of nights per week.
Among the dozen acts scheduled this month are burlesque
singer-comedians Nice Jewish Girls Gone Bad and rock group Groovelily,
giving four perfs of their holiday musical "Striking 12."
"We're not pulling our audience from the typical theater group
anymore," says David Brouillard, the Zipper's head of artist relations.
"We'll go from a room of crazy gays to nothing but a Brooklyn crowd in
Lower East Side club the Box uses a similar model, running its variety
act "Pandora" on Fridays and Saturdays, and frequently changing the
As hip as it is, though, a shifting array of edgy productions does have
its drawbacks. "Advertising for a venue like this becomes your worst
nightmare, because your crowds come from all over," says Brouillard.
"We're still discovering how to reach out to these people."
Plus, it can be hard to snare ticket-buyers when a show is unusual. "To
be honest, I'm not sure how we're going to get the message across about
what 'C'est Duckie' is," Foster confesses. "We have to rely on word of
But once the word is out, an act may have a new problem. If it becomes too popular, a show risks losing its offbeat cachet.
As they transitioned from downtown venues like Bowery Ballroom or the
now-defunct Fez, Kiki and Herb have faced the challenge of satisfying
their loyal long-term fan base while attracting the wider audiences
that larger houses demand. The Tiger Lillies started by playing dank
bars, but now have sold-out tours and several major theater awards
under their belts. "I do feel pressure to keep an edge," Jacques says.
"I'm always thinking of new subjects to provoke and stimulate my
Additionally, fame can attract audiences who may not embrace risky
material. This fall, the Zipper hosted an extended run of Margaret
Cho's adult revue "The Sensuous Woman," which featured plus-size
striptease artist Miss Dirty Martini doing things with a flag Betsy
Ross never dreamed of. Brouillard says not every patron was prepared
for transgender standup comics or a Chinese Cultural Revolution
striptease, with Cho getting down to pigtails, pasties and her artful
collection of tattoos.
"Sometimes you'd get a little nervous," he adds, commenting on the
audience members that wandered in unsuspectingly. "You'd think, 'I
don't think her gray hair is gonna make it to the end of the show.' "
Most artists would say a higher profile shouldn't affect the work.
Discussing the relative superstardom of Kiki and Herb, Bond avows he
hasn't softened his provocative, liberal edges.
"I never cater to a more mainstream taste," he insists. "I'd say when
we did Broadway, we had more specifically gay-themed material than
ever. We didn't say that stuff to some of our smaller audiences because
they already knew it."